You are Vital
Eyes Beyond Time

Why the Kidnapping?

Eyal yifrach Naftali frenkel Gilad Shaer

From left: Eyal Yifrach, Naftali Frenkel, Gilad Shaer

Animals react with instinct, for they lack the power of reason. If a dog is hit with a stick, it will growl at or bite the stick. Yet, the stick is not responsible for hurting the dog; the person who wields the stick is.

Much of the Israeli media has been blaming the police and the secret services here for all types of operative breakdowns that enabled the tragic kidnapping of the three Gush-Etzion yeshiva students, Eyal Yifrach, Gilad Shaer and Naftali Frenkel. So who is responsible?

Hashem is. The first principle of our faith as brought down by the Rambam is that Hashem alone, did, does and will do every deed. So, with emuna in mind, Hashem is responsible for the kidnapping and Hashem is also responsible for the three young men's safe return home from captivity, wherever they are. Hashem is responsible for the success of our security forces and is also responsible for their failure. Knowing this important fact, we no longer waste time on useless blame games but instead ask Hashem why He is doing this to us. By soul-searching and uprooting the spiritual reason that led to the kidnapping, we are doing the best we possibly can to bring Eyal, Gilad and Naftali home.

These three young men are absolute tzaddikim and are suffering for the sins of the Jewish People. This past year has been exemplified by unprecedented intramural Jewish hate, spearheaded by self-serving populist politicians. Hashem can't stand dissenion among His children. Yet, since the three yeshiva boys were kidnapped 17 days ago, all talk of dissension has ceased. The entire nation has come together. If the Hamas (or whoever else committed the crime of the kidnapping) knew that they'd contribute so much to Jewish unity in the Land of Israel, they'd have never allowed this to happen.

Today begins the new month of Tammuz. The notorious Three Weeks begin in another 17 days. Now is the time to love and accept one another and to uproot the ugly sinat chinam, the senseless intramural hate and dissension that caused both the Destruction of our Holy Temple and the kidnapping of our three cherished young men. G-d willing, with ahavat Yisrael, love and tolerance of one another, we'll get them back together with the bonus of Moshiach and our rebuilt Holy Temple, soon, amen.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


We definitely need to keep being united so we are strong. May Hashem see to it that our prayers are successful and redeem those captive young men soon, and send Moshiach




This is so true! Without the kidnapping, the IDF never would have discovered all the underground tunnels and bomb factories, and would not have arrested (and rearrested) all of the wanted terrorists that they found.

I have increased my tefillos, daven with more kavanah, and I light extra candles for the boys and their families every Shabbos.

May Hashem bring them home soon and restore them to their loving homes!

Marcelo Menezes

Amen v'Amen!!!


How can you stand in hashem's shoes, and say that the reason why hashem is making this terrible thing happen.

The comments to this entry are closed.