Dear Rabbi Lazer,
I'm sure if I wrote my biography, it would be a million-copy bestseller. In college, I went out with three different guys a week. Let's put it this way - there's not much I didn't do. With perfect poetic justice, I was diagnosed with breast cancer the week after I graduated. To make a long story short, I had a mastectomy. My doctor then urged me to have a contralateral prophylactic mastectomy. So here I was with the banner headlines of my once gorgeous body gone forever.
Really, that's when my happiness started. I turned to Hashem and became a complete baalas teshuva doing my best to repent for all my sins. I attended a seminar for newly observant young women like myself and loved every second of it. My teachers and the other girls were phenominal. Two years later, I was introduced to a wonderful guy from a Baal Teshuva Yeshiva who scrapped a successful electrical engineering career in order to learn Torah. I told him straight away that I wasn't packing The Manufacturer's standard equipment. He didn't care. I told him that I might have difficulty getting pregnant, but he also didn't care. "We'll both pray harder," he said with a smile.
Anyway, I've been married for four years now and we already have two children. My shalom bayis is the greatest, and my husband is not only the kindest, most gentle and loving person a woman could dream for, but he's fast becoming an giant in Torah learning. You wouldn't believe his humility despite his talents.
So what's my problem, Rabbi Lazer? Ever since I did teshuva, I've been doing everything possible to cleanse myself of the old sins, including saying Tikkun Klali every day, being super meticulous in the modesty of my appearance and head covering, exacting about every detail of kedusha (holiness - LB) above and beyond the basic laws of family purity, even guarding my eyes from looking at other men. Yet recently, I've been getting nasty flashbacks of the past during my most intimate time with my husband. You can't imagine my anguish and sorrow. I've been begging to Hashem every day to wipe the images of other men and my old sinning self off of my heart. I do an hour of hitbodedut every day. Yet nothing has helped. Am I so far from Hashem and teshuva that these flashbacks have returned to torment me? Why all of a sudden after a full two or three years that I didn't think about them? Rabbi Lazer, I'm sorry for this long letter and I know you're super busy, but I feel you're the only one that can understand me. I just can't spill my past out to any rabbi. Please help me. With deepest appreciation, Chani from Israel
Dear Chani,
I am really touched by your letter. Don't fret, everything is for the very best as you'll soon see. Not only does Hashem love you, but I guarantee you that you are one of His favorite daughters.
First, you ask about the nasty flashbacks, "Why all of a sudden after a full two or three years that I didn't think about them?" Rebbe Nachman of Breslev explains this clearly in Likutei Moharan (Part 1, Torah 25), namely, that when a person ascends to a higher spiritual level, he is bombarded with lusts and/or fantasies that he thought he had already overcome.
True, at your previous spiritual level, you had overcome the old garbage and had properly done teshuva. But, at your new spiritual level, you have to do more hard work to further cleanse the tiny blemishes that are still on your soul. In simple terms, you're now playing in a higher, more demanding league. You think you have digressed, but the opposite is true. You have made and are making fabulous spiritual progress.
Second, you anguish in seeing these nasty flashbacks is in itself a lofty form of teshuva. When they actually happened, you wantonly enjoyed every minute of what was going on. Now, when you see the same images, you are deeply disgusted and embarrassed. Rest assured that your anguish and embarrassment are better than a beautiful sin offering in the altar of our Holy Temple, may it be rebuilt soon, amen.
Chani, serve Hashem happily. Prayers with a song and smile are on a much higher level than prayers with tears. Just keep doing what you're doing, strengthen your emuna always, and you can forget about the nasty flashbacks. With your kind permission, I'll publish this letter (not revealing anything that might give away your true identity), and you'll have the merit of anyone that derives chizuk (strength) from it. With blessings always, LB